; Freecell.net Discussion Topic #16042
.net

Subject: Winning a stumper first try

Server time: Sun Nov 22 10:20

Date: Mon Dec 19 22:33:05 2022
User: Kaos
Message:
This will (hopefully) be a boring thread. The plan is if you win a game the first time you play it, and it was previously 0-20 or higher, feel free to crow here. Of course, by first time you play it, I mean the first time you play it. So, entering the game into a solver doesn’t count. Nor, does playing the game offline using any type of external aid count. You can only post if you solve the deal using your own mind and body and nothing else. So, I guess, if you track the use of freecells using your fingers or toes, that’s OK.

There are other threads that you can use to crow about hard games solved using other techniques. You know where they are. For those who play by these rules, feel free to repost good solves here that got lost 😞 in the abyss of posts in the thread filled with posts where games might have been solved on the 10th or 20th attempt; not the first.

Date: Mon Dec 19 23:04:08 2022
User: roo
Message:
Kaos, you haven't specified how or where the game arose, eg in streaking, tournament or posted on this discussion board (as 0/20 or more). Should that be a parameter?

Date: Tue Dec 20 21:02:36 2022
User: d164280a
Message:
11x0 11249-5 1/25 11x0 25662-5 1/40 first try brain only streaking.

Date: Tue Dec 20 22:48:44 2022
User: redberet
Message:
Those don't come very often, so I went looking. I came across this in someone's recent play and decided to give it a go. It was done in custom mode, no tricks up my sleeve.
Game: 7x3 30220-5
Game stats: 38/1/2.6%
Player Elo: n/a
Elapsed: 10:03
Streak: n/a

Date: Tue Dec 20 23:37:53 2022
User: WRAC
Message:
Good idea, Kaos. Let's hope the thread stays boring and non-controversial. :-)

In the spirit of the thread, I'll report this one from back on December 12 (the last game I won that met your criteria):

Game: 9x2 2141-11
Game stats: 24/1/4.2%/1971
Player Elo: 2077.803 ? 2.873
Elapsed: 7:24
Streak: 7

As always, I play with no aids (cards, notes, solvers, assistance from other people) and have no intention of ever doing otherwise.

Date: Wed Dec 21 17:56:06 2022
User: Kaos
Message:
redberet: That (7x3 30220-5) is an interesting game. It certainly looks winnable because there are so many good looking options. It just took me three attempts to find the right one.

the 9x2 was more of a challenge - six attempts. Just need to stare at that one a long time before moving.


Date: Wed Dec 21 23:00:29 2022
User: redberet
Message:
Winning one of these takes a whole lot of luck, plus a lot more skill. I do like the concept of matching wits. I tried and failed miserably on my one try with the 9x2. I'll give the 11x0 a go later. If I do get it on the one try, I'll be sure to crow.

Date: Thu Dec 22 09:38:58 2022
User: WRAC
Message:
Yes, lots of luck and lots of skill. (Unless you're Hop - then less luck is needed.)

7x3 30220-5 was fun and interesting. I surprised myself by getting it on the first try.

Game: 7x3 30220-5
Game stats: 42/3/7.1%
Player Elo: n/a
Elapsed: 9:46

Note: I typed the game number in wrong the first time and played 30225, won it, and said, well, that wasn't so hard... and then saw it was 12/32 and realized I had the wrong game. :-)

30220 is an excellent example of what makes 7x3 such an interesting variant. The best games, like this one, have multiple approaches, but it's not clear at the outset what will work and what won't.

Here's a 7x3 from the pre-Elo days (when I used to play a LOT faster, just to see what would happen, so obviously a lot of luck with this one):

Game #: 7x3 4588
Game stats: 88/1/1.14%
Difficulty: 5
Elapsed: 1:47
Streak: 3

I see this one is now 1/93.

And if you like 10x1s, here's another challenge for ya!

01/12/2021 17:01
Game #: 10x1 25807
Game stats: 58/1/1.72%
Difficulty: 5
Elapsed: 8:25
Streak: 8

This one is now 1/68.

Date: Thu Dec 22 12:43:50 2022
User: Purohit
Message:
69/2 and sorry no big deal.

Date: Thu Dec 22 12:51:52 2022
User: redberet
Message:
Thanks WRAC. I'll give 'em all a go. There is no downside, it won't cost me points. A good source of material exists in the recent play of the usual suspects. I would encourage all to seek that feather for your cap.

Date: Thu Dec 22 13:29:36 2022
User: smelly_cootiefied_fence_post
Message:
Now 3/73. Took me 4 tries, though, as there are so many pathways.

Date: Thu Dec 22 13:43:22 2022
User: redberet
Message:
No feather. First try need only apply.

I just think the subject is worthy.


Date: Thu Dec 22 13:47:52 2022
User: smelly_cootiefied_fence_post
Message:
Point taken. Such things are why I stink.

Date: Thu Dec 22 14:35:08 2022
User: redberet
Message:
On reflection, what I said was harsh. By commenting on how many tries it took, further validates the original winner's exceptional win, because sometimes those scores can be a by-product of a tournament game. Still no feather.

Date: Thu Dec 22 14:36:04 2022
User: WRAC
Message:
Another toughie from my past that some may find challenging:

Game #: 6x5 24545
Game stats: 50/1/2.00%
Difficulty: 5
Elapsed: 5:04
Streak: 8

Now 1/55.

Date: Thu Dec 22 15:11:10 2022
User: smelly_cootiefied_fence_post
Message:
Hey, ain't no thang. When one is as odiferous as I, one learns to absorb such things. I've got a thick, if somewhat putrid, skin. Your comment was accurate.

Date: Thu Dec 22 16:20:39 2022
User: Kaos
Message:
OK, the 7x3 above is obviously both a WRAC-friendly deal and a Kaos-friendly deal.

Game: 7x3 4588-5
Game stats: 94/2/2.1%
Player Elo: n/a
Elapsed: 2:17

I just hate to see I'm giving up 30 seconds on the time.


This one was from a month ago. It's the 2nd largest 0-something win I've ever had first try:

Game: 6x4 11268-5
Game stats: 76/1/1.3%/2310
Player Elo: 1847.102 ▲ 7.521
Elapsed: 3:47
Streak: 4
Today: 4


Date: Thu Dec 22 21:57:26 2022
User: Mastermind
Message:
On Jan 26th, 2020 Kaos wrote about game 6x5 11611 9. It was won first try with stats of 125/1. After close to three years now it is 158/4.
redberet, have a go at it.

Date: Thu Dec 22 22:42:05 2022
User: redberet
Message:
Came oh so close on the 7x3 4588. That 159/4 is a real beast.

Date: Thu Dec 22 23:07:50 2022
User: redberet
Message:
7x3-5 has a host of games that meet the criteria. Some go into the 100's. This is just a random cut and paste for those that'd like to partake. Waiting for nature to take its course, is well shaky.

315 33 0 0.00 1962.841
3069 33 0 0.00 1962.841
4033 33 0 0.00 1962.841
4516 33 0 0.00 1962.841
4743 33 0 0.00 1962.841
4956 33 0 0.00 1962.841
7928 33 0 0.00 1962.841
7979 33 0 0.00 1962.841
10151 33 0 0.00 1962.841
11906 33 0 0.00 1962.841

These are all 34/0. I'm quite sure some will succumb to the expertise that exists around here.

Date: Fri Dec 23 16:08:44 2022
User: Dr.Bombay
Message:
Mastermind, had to go back and look for that game and discussion. It was game #17 in the rotation:

#17 6x5 11611-9 3

Denny's tournament history doesn't show the losses. Obviously, calicokid also won it shortly after I did to be the 3rd to solve it.

Link: Masters where 6x5 11611-9 appeared.

Date: Sat Dec 24 21:13:21 2022
User: Klepp
Message:
Game: 12x0 28834-8

first of 7

Date: Sat Dec 24 21:50:29 2022
User: Klepp
Message:
Sorry, I now notice needing to be tougher than 0/20 for posting...no more mistakes like that, I promise.

Date: Sat Dec 24 22:46:52 2022
User: redberet
Message:
I gave this game a try. 7x3 31520-5 298/0.
It's at the moment the largest at that level. Take a special player to take it out. To me it's like the giant redwoods. Took years to grow. I'd hate to think that some lumberjack of spades will hack and a hew until she falls. But that's just me being sentimental.

Date: Sun Dec 25 12:39:25 2022
User: WRAC
Message:
I'm going to break the 20-play rule and post this game because I think it's worthy:

Game: 9x2 16834-10
Game stats: 12/1/8.3%/1965
Player Elo: 2121.335 ▲ 2.356
Elapsed: 13:41
Streak: 9

Or maybe you won't find it that tough? I'll be interested to know.

Date: Sun Dec 25 15:43:48 2022
User: calicokid
Message:
It's definitely worthy, lol.

I've had a few shots at it and have yet to crack it.

Date: Sun Dec 25 15:54:10 2022
User: redberet
Message:
It was a pre-qualified offer. Made some headway, but not where another try would have helped.

Date: Sun Dec 25 17:53:27 2022
User: Dr.Bombay
Message:
I second the motion from calicokid about 9x2 16834-10. It's now 33-1 so that certainly counts. FWIW, I think I have a better shot at redberet's 7x3 31520-5 298/0. At least I've gotten really close on it (which is likely why it has sooo many attempts).

Walking away from both of those with my tail between my legs, at least I know there are still Kaos-friendly games to be found since I got this one after switching to some 8x2 play:


Game: 8x2 18599-5
Game stats: 48/1/2.1%/2148
Player Elo: 1823.513 ▲ 7.007
Elapsed: 3:39
Streak: 3

Date: Sun Dec 25 18:57:30 2022
User: rbw--3
Message:
That 9x2 has multiple paths that look promising but fail. Congrats on winning that one.

Date: Mon Dec 26 02:17:53 2022
User: Purohit
Message:
CK, redberet, Dr.Bombay and rbw-3, clear column two and things will be clear(er!).

Unless WRAC had a magic wand, shouted " hey presto" and the cards moved themselves, this is the way he solved the game, I think.

Date: Mon Dec 26 03:48:54 2022
User: redberet
Message:
Made things much clearer Purohit.

Date: Mon Dec 26 08:34:37 2022
User: HopDiriDiriDattiriDittiriDom
Message:
That 9x2 can be won clearing column 8 first. I left the column 2 to the very end.

Date: Mon Dec 26 08:50:55 2022
User: Purohit
Message:
#7x3 25204 5
37/1 2.07%

Date: Mon Dec 26 09:05:06 2022
User: WRAC
Message:
Fascinating, Hop. Like Purohit, I cleared column 2 first.

Date: Tue Dec 27 05:36:16 2022
User: Uberman
Message:
This was one of those where it really was just about patience and considering all of the options in a process-of-elimination way, Didn't realise quite so much time had passed but hey, time flies when you're having fun, or at least fun in the traumatic sense.

6x4-5 #7075
62/1 - 1.6%

Date: Tue Dec 27 14:21:14 2022
User: datrox-3
Message:
Looking for an unwon but solvable deal I found this one. 21 tries later it was solved. Though there were only one tricky move it needed very careful play most of the time

Game: 6x6 31083-10
Game stats: 241/1/0.4%/2420
Elapsed: 5:13

Date: Tue Dec 27 17:19:18 2022
User: Kaos
Message:
Uberman, only 8 attempts totaling about twenty minutes for me. On the first three, it never looked winnable but on the 4th try, I had the right opening but just no patience whatsoever to finish it off. I think my biggest freecell flaw is having pretty much no patience whatsoever after getting deals about one third of the way home.

Date: Thu Dec 29 23:16:07 2022
User: roo
Message:
9x0 4032-5, 0/47 Elo was 2323. Easy to clear two columns. Made stupid mistake on the streak play, lost seven replays.

Date: Sat Jan 7 18:57:05 2023
User: ix
Message:
i'm posting it here also, i believe it well qualifies

datrox-3 did this

Game: 7x3 10711-5
Game stats: 50/1/2%/2033

Link: that game after datrox played it

Date: Sat Jan 7 19:13:35 2023
User: TNmountainman
Message:
It's likely that the previous game, which he won to make 3/50, damaged the dealer's psyche, causing a weakened next deal - or defenses against same.

Date: Sat Jan 7 20:04:20 2023
User: ix
Message:
on Dec 22 Mastermind posted:

On Jan 26th, 2020 Kaos wrote about game 6x5 11611 9. It was won first try with stats of 125/1

is this the record? has to be, right?

Link: https://www.freecell.net/f/c/disctopic.html?code=14018&replies=0

Date: Sun Jan 8 01:53:55 2023
User: Uberman
Message:
Well, I mean, it's not, but it's still very good.

Date: Fri Jan 27 16:11:24 2023
User: Dr.Bombay
Message:
I'm not sure this 8x2 is a personal record but has to be close:

Game: 8x2 22738-5
Game stats: 54/1/1.9%/2174
Player Elo: 1791.203 ▲ 7.263
Elapsed: 4:01
Streak: 2


Date: Mon Jan 30 04:43:56 2023
User: roo
Message:
1/30 4:38 9x0 16134-5 Not scored 3:53 Won 5% 2396 1 20

Not first try (replay of 0/19) but the alternative route which no-one took was very obvious.

Date: Sun Feb 5 02:47:31 2023
User: Uberman
Message:
An odd game that looks easy at first glance, then you suddenly stop as you realise you need to be careful, but once you've spotted the way out it becomes super easy again, so much so that I was expecting it to be a 90% game.

6x4 6100-5
102/5 4.9%
Elapsed: 3:54

Date: Sun Feb 5 14:46:20 2023
User: datrox-3
Message:
Uberman, I needed two tries. And I would have also expected a high winning percentage. The solution is obvious though careful play ist needed (therefore two tries).

Date: Sun Feb 5 21:56:11 2023
User: roo
Message:
Sorry, I don't get it. Gave up after several tries.

Date: Sun Feb 5 22:43:25 2023
User: datrox-3
Message:
What I meant by "obvious" is that the low cards are easily accessible. However, clearing the 6th column immediately doesn't work. The solution is to play the ace of diamonds home first. Play the 4 of spades to the 5 of hearts. Then clear the 6th column. The 7 of clubs and 6 of diamonds in column 6. After that, the low cards can be sent home.

Date: Mon Feb 6 01:36:26 2023
User: roo
Message:
Finally got it thanks datrox-3. I agree it's not a 5% game. I've done harder 90% 6x4s. It's probably a result of being level 5.

Date: Mon Feb 13 14:50:01 2023
User: datrox-3
Message:
Ha!

Game: 7x3 15927-5
Game stats: 75/1/1.3%/2086


Post follow-up
Username: You must be logged in to post. Click Play to create a free account.
Message:
Editor by summernote.org

All content copyright ©2026 Freecell.net
By using our games you consent to our minimal use of cookies to maintain basic state.
Maintained by Dennis Cronin