; Freecell.net Discussion Topic #6223.200
.net

Subject: College Football

Server time: Sat Nov 21 03:17

Date: Wed Oct 18 23:12:22 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

Bottom 10: Week 8




Date: Thu Oct 19 23:15:16 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

James Madison, newly FCS, is 6-0 after handling Marshall. Bowl eligible, but ineligible for a bowl game. 


Date: Fri Oct 20 10:07:21 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

In the last 2 minutes of game time of the James Madison/Marshall game, the announcers were bemoaning the insanity of the antiquated rules prohibiting JMU from participating in any postseason game because they are "transitioning" to FBS from FCS. The whining started out typical enough with mentions of the unfairness to the players who "work their butts off" and the silliness of the rule in general. Then, it got really ugly:

1) The announcers attacked the NCAA for being random in their enforcement of rules and always "making the wrong call"

2) They brought up the Tez Walker (UNC wide receiver) transfer case as being heavy handed and irrational

3) They called out former governor of Massachusetts, Charlie Baker, for being a politician and thinking and acting like one 

All of this is true and deserved, but we have never heard a major network (ESPN in this case) rip into the NCAA with such viciousness. Their back-and-forth screed lasted about five minutes in real time (due to all the normal timeouts at the end of a game), plenty of time for the producers and higher ups at ESPN to shut them off.

One could get the impression that this was scripted and intentional on the part of ESPN. We'll see what happens next. 


Date: Fri Oct 20 10:19:31 2023
User: Kumquat-of-Conciliation
Message:

Wow.  That's quite amazing.  Has mrbuck been brought in on this case - as he most definitely should be?


Date: Wed Nov 1 16:49:26 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

This is a rare evening for college football viewing. In Wednesday MACtion, we have a clash of Bottom 10 heavyweights: 1-7 Akron vs 1-7 Kent State. College Football Playoffs are still months away, but this game has all the trimmings of a championship. 6:30 PM on ESPNU.


Date: Sun Dec 3 20:59:16 2023
User: Dr.Bombay
Message:

Well, someone was going to get screwed after the conference championship results and it looks like Florida State drew the short straw.  I’d have been inclined to boot the SEC but past results came into the reckoning instead.  My simple logic: you had three big-five conference champions undefeated and two with a single loss.  Luckily, the two one loss champions already met in the regular season and Texas beat Alabama handily on the road.  Seems like an easy decision - especially after’Bama needed a brain cramp by an Auburn CB just to keep their one-loss record intact in the Iron Bowl.


Now, did I write this, or did it come from chatGPT?





Date: Sun Dec 3 21:39:34 2023
User: Dr.Bombay
Message:

Some complaints:  Now that 538 has sold out to ABC and Massey has stopped its computer rankings composite, it’s really hard to get any good (AKA unbiased) information on what’s mathematically most true about college football ( or life in general ).  Seems like every time some scientifically based website/newsfeed gains some traction, the owners sooner or later sell out to some scumbag multimedia conglomerate or tech giant.

As to US college football, a 6-team playoff makes the most sense of all (going back and forward).  This year you could have ‘Bama vs. FSU and UGA vs. Texas with the winners going on to play UW and UM respectively.




Date: Sun Dec 3 22:56:32 2023
User: TNmountainman
Message:

I couldn't believe it a few weeks ago when I went to the 538 site and saw it was now ABC 😲.  Actually meant to post something about it somewhere on this site - but wouldn't have been this thread.  I saw zero 'news' about it.  It's a loss.....   Sigh. 😕


Date: Mon Dec 4 12:52:25 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

FSU had every reason to believe that they would be in the playoffs: an undefeated big five conference champion had not been excluded before. They showed incredible resilience in their performances without their start quarterback. But, they also looked like a team that would get destroyed if they played a high-caliber offense. 

It's a bummer that the playoff sits at only four teams. A larger field would have included some worthy teams, particularly FSU. 

Next year...


Date: Wed Dec 13 17:08:17 2023
User: The_Longhorn
Message:

):o Florida State was robbed. Alabama should concede their spot.


):o Moo.


Date: Thu Dec 14 10:17:27 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

Why Alabama? Why not Michigan, Washington, or Texas? 


Date: Mon Dec 18 09:43:02 2023
User: TNmountainman
Message:

I didn't see it, but word is that the NDSU-Montana game was quite likely the best game in the country, by a longshot - at least 'til the national semis roll 'round.


Date: Tue Dec 19 13:11:34 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

I watched the game. It was a hard fought defensive battle for most of the game. Regulation ended 17-17, I believe. Montana's head coach is headed to USC to be their linebackers coach, but Montana agreed to let him coach through the playoffs. 

The overtime periods were excellent. Hard-nosed running game on both sides. 

On to Frisco TX on Jan 7 to face South Dak St for the championship. 


Date: Thu Dec 21 12:08:55 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

... and now Florida State wants to take their ball and go home. 

FSU considers leaving the ACC

Big-time college athletics has turned pro, and I'm not sure they are particularly good at it. With the NCAA having been rendered toothless, the rules are evaporating:

Marvin Harrison Jr being offered NIL deal bigger than a pro deal??? 

In the meantime, I watched the DIII and DII championship games, knowing that these kids are truly scholar athletes. The early DI bowls, as always, both meaningless and played at a very low level. Gratefully, the NFL will be playing on Thursday, Saturday, Sunday, and Monday of this week. I can get my football fix without watching a slew of NCAA games featuring 7-5 or 6-6 teams playing in empty stadiums. 



Date: Thu Dec 28 11:41:42 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

Against my better judgment, I had one of the bowl games on in the background as I prepared dinner last night. Va Tech vs Tulane. The Tulane qb's name is Horton, but the play-by-play dude was totally incapable of pronouncing it. For him, the man's name was Hor-uh. It was grating. A running back for Va Tech is named Tuten, and the pronunciation varied from Too-uh to Tuten. The idiot color commentator could pronounce both properly with no difficulty. 

This verbal affectation seems to be a trending thing, and I believe it's regional. (It absolutely is not ethnic or cultural.) Peyton Manning become Pay-uh.  Couldn't becomes cuh-uh.  

If there is a purpose to this, it is hi-uh from me. I really wish this di-uh exist. 


Date: Thu Dec 28 14:17:20 2023
User: BrewCrewOldSkool
Message:

What the fricative?


Date: Fri Dec 29 06:33:35 2023
User: TNmountainman
Message:

Buzz, I was thinking that affliction/affectation was generational.  Certainly around here it is.


Date: Sun Dec 31 00:39:11 2023
User: Dr.Bombay
Message:

FSU really showed the FBS that they made the wrong decision 😉


Date: Sun Dec 31 07:03:37 2023
User: TNmountainman
Message:

Well................with a GIGANTIC asterisk of the Seminoles being without 28 players - some injured, but many sitting out for portal or future-NFL reasons.  The outcome would likely have been the same, but far, far less egregious.  GA's coach made strong comments to that effect, politely(?) calling out the NCAA to somehow "fix" the problem. 


Date: Sun Dec 31 09:36:12 2023
User: BuzzClik
Message:

Kirby Smart's comments were on the money: nobody want this. Next year with 12 playoff teams, there will still be bowl games outside of the playoffs. 

Opt-outs (NFL prospects avoiding injury) have always diminished bowls, but the transfer portal is the biggest problem. Massive numbers of starting players are bolting to other teams -- not for starting positions but for money. These kids, many of whom will NEVER have the talent to play pro ball, are getting paid 6 and 7 figures for one year of mediocre play. NCAA FBS is rapidly turning into the crappiest pro league on the planet. 


Date: Mon Jan 1 21:53:13 2024
User: Dr.Bombay
Message:

Well, the FBS selection committee sent the message to the ACC, that they were least among the big money conferences (helped by the fact that the other  weak sister, the PAC-12, had a banner year).  And, Louisville losing was part of the same self-fulfilling prophecy.  


Speaking of next year’s revision: It would be interesting to know if said Louisville would have made it into a cut of 12.  I’m guessing it would have been a no.  Especially with having to include undefeated Liberty - hardly a top-30 team.


Date: Tue Jan 2 01:00:58 2024
User: Dr.Bombay
Message:

Whoa, great outcome from my perspective with Michigan and Washington making it to the national championship final.  What’s really ironic is that they were the #1 and #2 seeds by the FBS Committee and both big underdogs by the Las Vegas crowd.  Of course, the pros setting the betting lines in Las Vegas are balancing the perceptions of the betting public against what they actually believe will transpire.


Date: Tue Jan 2 09:16:23 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

Louisville finished 15 in the rankings. They were an unlikely pick for a 12-team playoff. Liberty would have had no guarantees. 

The two semifinal games were such a breath of fresh air compared to the miserable bowl games. It was great to see four teams with no opt-outs, no late-season transfers playing at a high level. 

ESPN's Game Day had a lively debate about canning the non-playoff bowl games moving forward. The only strong voice in favor of killing the worthless bowls was Herbstreit. McAfee and Galloway (both former players) were emphatic that the players spent their whole lives preparing for football and "they earned the right for a post season game." That was the dumbest logic ever. This year, four teams "earned the right" for a post season game (three total games). The other FORTY bowl games -- EIGHTY TEAMS -- fell short and earned nothing. Participation ribbons all around and a trophy for everyone. 



Date: Tue Jan 2 09:45:31 2024
User: BrewCrewOldSkool
Message:

Capitalism dictates the other bowls won't go anywhere, may still even proliferate (market determination).


Date: Tue Jan 2 12:29:24 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

I hear you, Brewski, but the bottom-feeder bowls are barely scratching a profit. The participating schools are obligated to buy a huge block of tickets that are nearly impossible to pawn off on the fans. Add the costs of getting the team (cheerleaders, and maybe the band) to the game and housing them, and the costs are significant. Quite often, the schools lose money because the low-end bowls have a miserable payout. The stadiums are nearly empty, so it's not like the good folks of the hosting town care about the game. 

I had YouTube TV set to record all the bowl games, but only watched about 10 of them, and only three to completion. And that includes the high-end, non-playoff bowls. I'll watch all the new playoff games and none of the 2024 Green Ribbon bowls. 


Date: Tue Jan 2 13:29:55 2024
User: BrewCrewOldSkool
Message:

"The stadiums are nearly empty"...I suspect so Buzz, but cable, satellite, and pay-per-view's ad dollars is a tough pest to control, much less terminate.


Date: Thu Jan 4 11:58:13 2024
User: TNmountainman
Message:

One can, of course, be a fan of whatever team one wishes.........................but.............I simply can't understand how one could pull for cheaters in this post-season (or at any other time, for that matter):

Doyel: National title for Harbaugh's cheating would render college football meaningless (msn.com)

Now, to be clear.............I'm no fan of 'bama and Saban, as they've won FAAAR too many titles for their 'fair share', but vs. the blatant Harbaugh antics.............


Date: Thu Jan 4 13:56:42 2024
User: BrewCrewOldSkool
Message:

Go Huskies.


Date: Sat Jan 6 13:46:22 2024
User: TNmountainman
Message:

We pretty much know all this, but it's a well-written analysis/lament:

Opinion: Welcome to the end of college football as we know it | CNN


Date: Sat Oct 5 09:10:07 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

Miami plays Cal in Berkely today in the conference opener. ACC, baby!


Date: Sun Oct 6 08:02:32 2024
User: outskirts
Message:

VANDY 


Date: Sun Oct 6 13:24:10 2024
User: TNmountainman
Message:

Not sure what you're meaning with the comment about the Cal-Miami game being the conference opener.  All ACC teams have now played at least two conference games, other than Pitt.  I think it's hilarious that Fla St. (sorry, olblue), who's suing the ACC, and wants out (presumably because they're too good, and want into either the SEC or BigWhatever - but are being rebuffed, at least for now), and was nationally-ranked at the beginning of the season, is now 1-4 in-conference.


Date: Sun Oct 6 14:25:20 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

No idea about the “conference opener.” Somebody said it on Game Day, and I repeated it without checking. 

Not only did Miami travel 2500 miles to get to the game, it started at 10 pm Miami time. 


Date: Sun Oct 6 19:04:31 2024
User: olblue
Message:

No problem, TN...I have to laugh at the way we're playing this year.  It's either that or pull my hair out by the roots.


Date: Tue Oct 15 07:50:10 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

Tuesday night football? Yeah, baby!

Tonight we have three games featuring (in alphabetical order): Kennesaw State, Louisiana Tech, Middle Tennessee, New Mexico State, South Alabama, and Troy. The games begin at 7:30 PM EDT. 

The teams have a combined record of  7-27 with La Tech leading the the pack at 2-3. 

You'll need access to ESPN2, CBSSN, and/or ESPNU. Enjoy. 


Date: Sat Oct 19 07:41:10 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

BYU needed a last-second TD to beat truly awful Oklahoma State. BYU is undefeated and ranked 13th, on the brink of the national playoff. BYU has a couple of tests remaining: 4-2 Utah, 5-1 Arizona State, and the Big 12 Playoff championship. The Big 12 championship game pits the teams with the best records in the conference, so that should be a good game. Both teams in the championship game have a chance of advancing to the national playoffs. 

BYU in the playoffs would be everything right and everything wrong with the new playoff structure. 


Date: Sun Oct 20 10:51:14 2024
User: TNmountainman
Message:

Nevermind.....


Date: Sun Oct 20 11:04:27 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

There seem to be some sensitivities at work here. Maybe a 'Noles fan taking umbrage?

One of the three ongoing screeds about big streaks in 8x4 was trimmed as well. Are we censoring somebody who questions the veracity of claims of being an ordained man of the cloth?


Date: Sun Oct 20 11:17:23 2024
User: TNmountainman
Message:

To be clear....................the (majority of, at least) Seminole commentary was/still is in the "Interesting sports tid-bits thread", but yeah, there was some erasure going on.


Date: Sun Oct 20 12:14:04 2024
User: olblue
Message:

I'm not sure about any Seminole erasure going on a 'Noles fan taking umbrage but I can assure you if any posts were deleted it wasn't me!  


Date: Sun Oct 20 12:16:23 2024
User: TNmountainman
Message:

Cool.  And..........just out of curiosity, is there a healthy support group system for those who may be affected?


Date: Sun Oct 20 13:56:47 2024
User: olblue
Message:

I'm sure there are many Seminole fans today who are in dire need of a support group system.  The Seminoles have been on top before and now on the bottom, I'm sure one day they'll be back on top again, won't be this year or the next but one day....


Date: Mon Nov 11 14:48:28 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

The Holy War concluded late on Saturday with BYU coming back from a large deficit to squeak by Utah (playing at Utah). On their final drive, the BYU quarterback was sacked on fourth down at about their own 1 yard line, but an official flagged one of the Utah defenders for holding on a receiver. The Utah crowd went crazy, the coach lost his mind, and the BYU cashed in with a late field goal to win the game. 

During post-game interviews, Utah athletic directed, Mark Harlan, took to the podium to declare this: "This game was absolutely stolen from us,” Harlan said. “We were excited about being in the Big 12, but tonight I am not. We won this game. Someone else stole it from us. Very disappointed. I will talk to the commissioner. This was not fair to our team. I’m disgusted by the professionalism of the officiating crew tonight.”

The Big 12 was less than amused. They publically reprimanded Harlan and fined him $40,000.

Gotta love Harlan's leadership. The best part of this is that the BYU receiver absolutely positively was held. The defensive back grabbed the receiver by the arm and nearly pulled him to the ground. 


Date: Mon Nov 11 15:40:32 2024
User: TNmountainman
Message:

And who, on their bingo card, had the last 4 unbeaten 1-A teams as being Oregon, BYU, Army, and Indiana??


Date: Mon Nov 11 16:11:26 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

Indeed. 

Three of the four are in the Top 10, and Army is lurking in the mid-teens. Army has three significant games remaining: Notre Dame, UTSA (yeah, they are pretty good), and Navy. If they win out, they are a slam dunk. It is possible that they could sneak in with one loss if the football gods are kind to them. 

Indiana has a bye week followed by Ohio State and Purdue. They could easily get in with one loss. 

Oregon has Wisconsin and Washington. An Oregon/Indiana BigTen championship?

BYU and Kansas and Houston left, and then the Big12 championship. 

Two of the four could be undefeated headed into the national playoffs. 


Date: Sat Nov 30 17:29:57 2024
User: BrewCrewOldSkool
Message:

Credit the Michigan placeholder, that snap was way up and headed right at him.


Date: Sun Dec 1 10:19:57 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

The College Football Playoff is absolutely doing what its supposed to do: ensure that the top teams are in the playoffs, and turn the conversation to the lower seeds. Losses this week will not spell exclusion for Ohio State or Miami, and wins for Georgia, Tennessee, SMU, and Indiana should cement their inclusion. Folks won't like the high seed for Boise State or that Arizona State jumps over more worthy teams, but there's no doubt that the best 8 teams will be in the field. 

Championship weekend should be fun. 


Date: Sun Dec 1 16:54:32 2024
User: BrewCrewOldSkool
Message:

I suppose I'll root for SMU, OU or BSU, or any team that battles ND.


Date: Sun Dec 1 17:05:44 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

ditto that


Date: Tue Dec 3 15:21:50 2024
User: BuzzClik
Message:

For the first time in a couple months, no college football on Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday. Woe is me. 



Post follow-up
Username: You must be logged in to post. Click Play to create a free account.
Message:
Editor by summernote.org

All content copyright ©2026 Freecell.net
By using our games you consent to our minimal use of cookies to maintain basic state.
Maintained by Dennis Cronin